Future of the Home Embroidery Industry

For quite some while now, I have been watching the introduction of all brands of new embroidery machine models introduced this year, or to be introduced in the near future. I believe it was the Pfaff “Dream Machine” that started the trend of newer, better, bigger, and expensive machines…..the key words being bigger and expensive, they all are definitely that.

A trip to various dealers and doing a test drive on them really makes me wish that these were around when I first started machine embroidery. As machines go, they are all Top of the Line machines with amazing features and lots of improvements. The only drawback with all of them….they make me wish I had deeper pockets. When I had first purchased my Deco about 10 years ago, I had thought $1700 for a machine was an extremely high price (but then the value of dollar was quite high too…). When I sold it to purchase a ULT for about $3000 I believed that I had arrived at the apex of embroidery machines. That was a short lived thought until I purchased the PR 600 for $10,000! I do believe DH believed that my machine purchasing days were over and I did too….that is until I saw a commercial machine in action, LOL. That put a dent of a mere $12,000 in my pockets…Surprised! I was. A semi-commercial machine being equivalent to the cost of a commercial machine!

My first ever embroidery machine had a hoop size of 4×4 which upgraded to 5×7 to 6×10 in the ULT and then to 7×11 with the PR. See the trend….larger hoop size. And, why ever not! However, with the latest prices of the embroidery machines, I had to sit back and do a bit of thinking. I can still remember making a 34″x34″ table topper using the 4×4 hoop and with designs from the retired Cross stitch Borders collection. True, there was a bit of calculating and a bit of work involved in making such a large design with only the 4×4 hoop, but the end result was phenomenal. The largest hoop size that my SWF can accomodate is 20″x14″ and I do love it. The PR 600 purchased six years ago with a smaller hoop field is almost equivalent to the price of the SWF. True, I cannot move the SWF at all, it has to stay put where the PR can be moved by two people very easily. Bigger hoop size has been a dream for many many home embroiderers…however, dreaming something and getting something are two different things. What is the perfect hoop size for a home machine embroiderer….the bigger the better, LOL. Unfortunately, in my opinion, I believe it is this wishful thinking that has produced another greater problem….higher prices.

So…friends…what is going on. The TOL new embroidery machines in the market range from $8000 to $12,000. Those prices can very well be a down payment on a car! Why are the prices so high and is there really that much demand in the home embroidery industry? I am not too sure about the answers but I can certainly put a few gray cells to work, LOL. Well over twelve/thirteen years ago, home embroidery machines were introduced as a hobby machine and few were interested in them. With internet came a lot of changes…people could communicate, learn and share ideas. I can still remember embroidering for three days straight (without any sleep) on my Deco, anything and everything that came in sight. I had a folder of all the built in designs in several color schemes!! True, I was drawn to it at my Bernina dealer but it was on the internet that I learned all types of things that could be embroidered, embellished and enhanced with the machine. Not only did I purchase the machine from my Bernina dealer but I was also encouraged and coaxed to purchase the PE Design as well as the Customizer. I knew that the PED would help me make my own designs but had no idea what the Customizer was about until two years later. With about $3500 invested in the machine and software, I embarked upon my embroidery journey. I have never regretted a moment of it and have enjoyed it tremenduously.

In the past, and even now I have always maintained that the home digitizers have developed the machine embroidery industry into being something that was never thought about nor dreamt about. A handful of commercial concerns were the only ones who sold designs when I first came on the scene…until I discovered the internet and home digitizers! The low prices were certainly a great attraction and one learned to cope with the digitizing irritants. With time, the ideas and imaginations of the home digitizers have grown to such great extremes and became in high demand by the home embroidery industry, that for the past seven years, the commercial companies have felt the hurt and the need to compensate. Whole catalogs of commercial companies with thousands of designs once sold for high dollars are now being sold for a pittance…recent ad of one of the companies which sold their entire catalog for a mere $300! Not just that, commercial digitizers started seeking home embroidery shows and dealers to promote their products….aha, a picture starts to form.

It is my belief and opinion that the rising costs of the home embroidery machines and the supplies is due to the fear of the commercial industry “biting the dust” so to speak in the face of the home embroidery digitizers and enthusiasts! Big words, you say, yes they are indeed. But, how far am I from the truth? Embroidery supplies and machines were expensive way back when and in the course of time became easily accesible and therefore became the “thorn” for the commercial industry. Raise the prices, less people will purchase and the commercial industry will regain its lost caliber. Spending well over $10,000 for an embroidery machine with well over hundreds every few months for supplies is a high cost hobby. If the hobby is high cost, then few will partake of it and when few partake, somebody loses but someone also gains. And in my opinion, it is not the home embroidery market that will boom with high prices of supplies! Where is this going to lead to and what will eventually happen? My guess….the end of a wonderful hobby for thousands. I do hope that time has come for the commercial embroidery market to realise the co-existance of the home embroidery digitizers and their influence in the market. Meanwhile…will these high cost machines sell? Absolutely yes but not as much as before. The real question will be when these high tech and high cost babies require maintenance.  My mother had a Singer sewing machine which lasted her for well over twenty years….when she sold it, it was still purring when it ran. I sincerely hope and believe that the best thing for the home embroidery machine companies is to better the products already in the market. This should be done by electronically upgrading the existing machines rather than flooding the market with embroidery machines which few will be able to afford and maintain especially when there are limited use clauses on them.

And where does this lead yours truly and many of my other fellow digitizers. Just like before and with better and newer techniques and ideas. It is definitely a time for recognition and in my humble opinion, recognition is not made with $$ rather with quality and imaginative products.  

Comments (5)

Cindy PowersOctober 15th, 2008 at 5:50 am

This is such a thought-provoking post that I’m surprised no one else has commented yet. As usual, you offer a very sharp insight and were ahead of the curve on this financial downturn we currently find ourselves in. One does have to wonder what the market will be for these extravagantly more expensive machines that have become available of late.
Regards,
Cindy

SadiaOctober 19th, 2008 at 8:50 pm

Thank you Cindy for your kind post, I appreciate it. From what I hear from the dealers, the machines are selling and will sell due to the plans offered with them. However, where does this leave so many of us who will not purchase the new ones but would like updates which were promised to us when we purchased our machines, which were the TOL at that time. It is an extremely important thought and I hope by writing it here that we can question and make a change. Its always a hope. Hope you are doing well. Have not been to your blog in a while but I will definitely check it out. HUGS, Sadia

Patsy SweetraNovember 18th, 2008 at 11:21 am

Sadia, my reaction to these new monster TOL’s was to rebel! I especially rebelled at the $12,000 machine! Like you, I fear that fielding more and more expensive machines will “do in” the industry! And the reverse of that will be the folks who almost have to re-mortgage their homes to buy these things? That saddens me.Do these monster machines really do anything revolutionary for the home embroidery industry? I think not. I think is shows utter lack of foresight on the part of the machine companies in terms of what the market will bear! I know R&D is always months, if not years, ahead of fielding the machines, but OMG, $12,000? I am put in mind of those old cartoons where the rich guy is lighting a cigar with a $20.00 bill and driving a monster of a car with all the bells and whistles on it. Just not something I am interested in. It becomes absolute vulgarity in the face of an economy where there is still hunger in the world! A lot of the fiber artists/sewing community does a lot of “giving back”. I think it is time supporting industries perhaps think about doing some of the same thing. Just my humble opinion.

Linda PerkinsNovember 19th, 2008 at 12:44 pm

Sadia,

I agree. I would love a new embroidery machine. I have a Brother PE400D that only has a 4 x 4 field. I have had so much fun with it and still really enjoy using it when I am not doing homework. ( I have gone back to school.) But when I heard that the new TOL machines were $12,000 I knew that there would never be one in my future. I really feel that even if the economy was not in the tank that there is no way that I can justify that much of an expense on an item that is a hobby. How do machine manufacturers think that the average home hobbyist will be able to afford that much for a sewing machine. Then they lament that no one is sewing now. Well of course not when it is so far out of reach of the average person. Then you have dealers who are only interested in customers who buy the TOL machines. I do know that when I upgrade it will be to a “new to me” machine. With the high cost there are no more new machines in my future.

I do really think that you are right in regards to what is going on in the industry and it saddens me because in many ways machine companies are missing out on the huge numbers of people who would sew if they had more middle of the road options.

Thanks for an insightful post.

Friends, Linda

SadiaJanuary 28th, 2009 at 1:22 am

I’m sorry that I never replied to your comments. But I have to say that Patsy and Linda….both your posts brought out shivers. The reason…very simple. Look at the dates and look at what is going on. Patsy, you are absolutely right about the industry giving back. I have to admit it has been lacking. Thank you both. Hugs, Sadia

Leave a comment

Your comment